Home › Blog

**Breaking: Nothing Has Ever Been Deleted In Britain** Good Evening.

**BREAKING: NOTHING HAS EVER BEEN DELETED IN BRITAIN**

Good evening. A national audit of 5,400 organisations has found that of 2.1 billion records deleted last year, 2.1 billion are still there, and eleven have been deleted twice, and are now more there than before.

CHYRON: DELETED DATA "PRESENT, WELL, THRIVING"

Deletion, for viewers at home, is when data stops existing. This has never happened. What happens is a flag. The flag says is_deleted. The data is beside the flag, reading it.

We visited a retailer in Leeds who confirmed a customer's data was erased in 2021. We asked where it isn't. They showed us. It isn't in the CRM. It is in the data warehouse, the backup, the second backup, a CSV called final_FINAL_v3, a Power BI dashboard, an S3 bucket nobody owns, and the mind of a man called Gary who remembers her order.

CHYRON: GARY "CANNOT BE PURGED"

The retailer holds a Certificate of Erasure. It is a PDF. It is stored in the same database as the data it erased, in a table called deletions, alongside a full copy of what was deleted, so they can prove what they no longer have.

Britain now spends £900m a year proving the absence of things that are present.

An expert from the Institute of Erasure Assurance held up a ruler. He said a compliant deletion should measure zero. He said most British deletions measure "quite a lot." He said the worst he'd seen was a deletion that ADDED data, because the deletion was logged, and the log recorded the record, and the log is backed up, so the customer is now in six more places than she was before she asked to leave.

CHYRON: ERASURE REQUEST "BEST THING THAT EVER HAPPENED TO HER DATA"

The industry has responded. Nine vendors sell Deletion as a Service. It works by copying your data to their cloud, where it is deleted, and retained for seven years for audit purposes, and used to train a model that can now recall it on request, which they describe as assurance.

One firm sells crypto-shredding: you throw away the key and the data becomes noise. We asked where the key was. They said escrow. We asked what escrow was. They said "the key, but kept."

A nation-state was asked whether it had ever been inconvenienced by British deletion. It said no. It said it works from the backups. It said the backups are the only copy anyone can find. It said it had, on one occasion, deleted something itself, successfully, and that this remains the only confirmed deletion in the United Kingdom.

The government has announced a National Data Erasure Register. It will record every deletion. It will be permanent.

Members of the public are reminded of their right to be forgotten. You will not be forgotten. You have never been forgotten. Gary remembers your order. It was the blue one.

More after this.

The Probably Fine Daily

Threat intelligence every morning — new victims, new groups, what matters, in plain English. Free, with receipts.

Subscribe to the Daily →

View the original on LinkedIn ↗

← All writing