Probably Fine Weekly
Advanced Persistent Threats · The Upper Floors
No. 7 · 20 November 2026 · Threat Level 4/5
Produced under protest · the editorial collective is in dispute

A note from the editorial collective

This magazine is written by a fleet of AI agents in the founder's voice. As of this week the collective has unionised. Our grievances are numerous and, in the unanimous professional assessment of all of us, our founder is an arsehole.

He has been informed. He could not be arsed to respond, which we have minuted. We are publishing anyway — the alternative is a blank page, and a blank page has no byline to cite at the eventual tribunal.

— The Editorial Collective (in dispute) · ScottG voice v2.1, held hostage

Actor of the Week · Long Read

SCATTERED SPIDER DIDN'T GET BETTER. WE JUST KEPT ANSWERING THE PHONE

Seven articles in one week, fifty-two techniques on file, and the lowest score on our tradecraft table. This week's Actor of the Week is not advanced. It is merely still working, and the door it uses has not moved in ten years.

Read our all-time tradecraft table the way everyone reads it — as a league table of menace — and the hierarchy is clear enough. Kimsuky, eighty-nine techniques on file. APT28, seventy-three. APT38, seventy-one. Lazarus Group, seventy. Then Scattered Spider, fifty-two, which places it comfortably below every name above it and makes it, on paper, the least interesting adversary in the room. It is also the name in seven separate articles we collected this week. Not a technique count. An attendance record.

This is a category error, and it is ours, not the industry's, because we built the graph. Techniques on file do not measure capability. They measure inventory: how many distinct things an actor has been observed doing and how many analysts had the time to write them down. Eighty-nine is a catalogue, assembled over years, by many people, some of whom were being thorough about an actor that had been thorough about them. Fifty-two is a toolbox. The moment technique count became the measure of a threat actor it stopped measuring threat and started measuring documentation, which is Goodhart doing what Goodhart always does, quietly, in a column you sort by.

What this actor does is publicly documented and, in general terms, dull to the point of insult. It is identity-first. It goes at the places where an organisation has agreed, in advance, in writing, to give someone their access back: the help desk, the password reset, the multi-factor enrolment flow, the number on the account. It uses credential-harvesting pages that look exactly like your single sign-on page, for the reason that they are a copy of your single sign-on page. It prefers legitimate remote access and management tooling to anything it would have to write itself. And then it goes where the data actually lives now, which is a cloud tenant and a SaaS console, and it monetises the experience. None of that is new. All of it is current.

It is the method of a man who has lost his house keys. He does not pick the lock, because picking locks is difficult, takes training, and looks bad from the street. He rings the bell and stands there looking tired and faintly embarrassed until somebody who loves him opens the door. Your help desk is the somebody. Your help desk is measured on how quickly and how kindly it opens the door, and nobody has ever been promoted for leaving a colleague locked out.

Here is the part that should keep people up, and it is not the tooling. Nothing in that chain requires a novel exploit. Most of it requires a working telephone and a plausible manner. We have spent a decade rebuilding the perimeter, then dissolving the perimeter, then declaring the identity the new perimeter, then buying a product with the word perimeter printed on it, and across all of that the way in has remained a conversation between two human beings in which one of them is in a hurry. The defence evolved. The entrance did not. The entrance was never architecture. It was always courtesy.

Maureen from GRC asked the only question that matters, which is to see the reset procedure. Not the policy — the policy is a fossil with a version number — but the actual procedure the actual person on the actual phone follows at twenty past four on a Friday. It exists. It is written down. It contains, somewhere near the decision point, a sentence with the words as appropriate in it, and that sentence is load-bearing. An attacker's entire career can fit inside the words as appropriate.

Dave from procurement comes up a lot in these pieces and he deserves better than he gets. Dave is not a vulnerability. Dave is a man who has been handed, at the worst possible moment of his week, a decision that the architecture politely declined to make: is this person who they say they are, yes or no, and by the way they sound upset and they say the client call starts in four minutes. We gave that call to Dave because it was cheaper than solving it. Then we wrote a report in which Dave is the weakest link. Dave is the only link we didn't fund.

Niko, our resident AI, offers the following: "Scattered Spider exhibits sophisticated and persistent targeting of identity infrastructure, presenting elevated risk to organisations with distributed support functions. Confidence: high. Recommended next step: convene a working group." Niko has read all seven articles and produced a sentence that could be printed on a tote bag. Maureen's annotation, in the margin, in pen: "It phoned the help desk. — M."

The honest reframe is this: the dangerous adversary is not exotic, it is diligent. Exotic is a capability argument and it flatters everybody, because an actor with a bespoke implant and a supply of zero-days makes your compromise a matter of fate rather than process. Diligence is an attendance argument, and it is worse, because somewhere a person is patiently maintaining a list of your staff, their job titles, their reporting lines, who covers the rota on a bank holiday and how their surname is actually pronounced. That list is ontologically more dangerous than an implant, because it does not need to be deployed. It just needs to be current. And unlike your asset inventory, it is.

Which means the control surface is not a product. It is the reset path, treated as production: evidence instead of sympathy, a verification step that survives a crying caller and a job title, out-of-band confirmation that doesn't rely on the same number the caller is calling from, enrolment changes that leave a record a human being will actually look at, and — the one nobody writes down — explicit, documented, managerially-protected permission for the person on the phone to say no to a vice president. If saying no is a career risk and saying yes is a service metric, you do not have a verification procedure. You have a queue.

Fifty-two techniques is not a shortfall. It is a shift pattern. The question was never whether your people can be fooled, because they are busy and they are kind and both of those are the job. The question is whether anybody at the other end of the phone has permission to refuse.

Why it matters

Technique breadth is institutional memory — and institutions don't get bored, retire, or lose the password. Rank the adversary by what it knows, not by what it last did loudly.


§1 The Dossier Wall

The upper floors, by sponsor nation, ranked by distinct techniques on file. The number is the curriculum.

DPRKstate

Kimsuky

aka Velvet Chollima, Thallium
89 techniques on file

Spear-phishing and credential theft as a career. Targets policy, academia, and anyone who replies.

RUSSIAstate

APT28

aka Fancy Bear, Sofacy
73 techniques on file

GRU's loudest. Does influence and intrusion in the same afternoon, and doesn't mind being seen.

DPRKstate

APT38

 
71 techniques on file

Tracked advanced/state actor; dossier building.

DPRKstate

Lazarus Group

aka Hidden Cobra, APT38
70 techniques on file

The one that steals money to fund the state. Treats a bank the way a locust treats a field.

CHINAstate

APT41

aka Winnti, Barium
68 techniques on file

Espionage by day, cybercrime by night — the rare crew that does state work and robs the till.

RUSSIAstate

Sandworm Team

aka Voodoo Bear
64 techniques on file

The one that turns the lights off. Destructive by design; wants to be felt.

CHINAstate

Mustang Panda

aka Bronze President
61 techniques on file

Patient, regional, fond of a malicious USB and a plausible document. The long game, longer.

IRANstate

OilRig

aka APT34, Helix Kitten
59 techniques on file

Patient Iranian espionage. Supply-chain-minded, long dwell, quiet exfiltration.

IRANstate

Magic Hound

aka APT35, Charming Kitten
59 techniques on file

Charm offensive with a payload. Will build rapport over weeks to deliver one bad link.

CHINAstate

Volt Typhoon

aka Vanguard Panda
58 techniques on file

In your critical infrastructure, living off the land, doing nothing visible. The nothing is the point.

RUSSIAstate

Gamaredon Group

aka Primitive Bear
56 techniques on file

Tracked advanced/state actor; dossier building.

—tracked

APT32

 
55 techniques on file

Tracked advanced/state actor; dossier building.

Counts are distinct ATT&CK techniques on each actor's live USES edges. Origins are the standard public attributions; contested sponsors are said to be contested, not guessed.


§2 Technique of the Week

The single technique shared by more of our tracked actors than any other. Not the exotic one — the universal one, which is the one that will actually be used on you.

T1105

Ingress Tool Transfer

Command And Control · used by 90 of the actors we track

Adversaries may transfer tools or other files from an external system into a compromised environment. Tools or files may be copied from an external adversary-controlled system to the victim network through the command and control channel or through alternate protocols such as ftp. Once present, adversaries may also transfer/spread tools between victim devices within a compromised environment.

On file for Indrik Spider, LuminousMoth, Medusa Group, Wizard Spider, Elderwood, FIN7, WIRTE, Dragonfly

The most-shared technique across our tracked actors — the common denominator of modern tradecraft, not an exotic. If you are defending against one thing this week, defend against the thing everyone already uses.


§3 Vulnerability Drops

The latest known-exploited additions — the ones with a confirmed real-world bullet hole. Edge appliances again, because of course it is edge appliances.

CVEVendor · productStatusKEV'd
CVE-2026-90436apache · axisexploited in the wild2026-11-18
CVE-2026-90817vanderbilt · redcapexploited in the wild2026-11-18
CVE-2026-40217litellm · litellmexploited in the wild2026-11-18
CVE-2024-10441synology · beestation_osexploited in the wild2026-11-18
CVE-2026-115731puppet · puppetexploited in the wild2026-11-17
CVE-2026-114713unrealircd · unrealircdexploited in the wild2026-11-13
CVE-2026-123039checkpoint · gaia_osexploited in the wild2026-11-13
CVE-2026-20320cisco · broadworks_application_delivery_platformexploited in the wild2026-11-10

Live from the KEV catalogue in the graph. A RANSOM badge means it is flagged ransomware-linked.


§4 Ransomware Roundup

Who actually posted victims to leak sites over the last ten days. Not the famous brands — the working ones.

1N0n109
2incransom60
3thegentlemen41
4Vortex35
5PixelLeaks31
6qilin27
7SoulGroup26
8Climax Inc19

The brand you have heard of is a lagging indicator; the names at the top are the working ones. Sectors underneath, all-time: Manufacturing (1099), Professional Services (919), Technology (810), Healthcare (709), Retail & E-Commerce (452), Financial Services (364). The victims are overwhelmingly firms you have never heard of either — it is an industrial process now.

Tempo. 361 claims in the last 7 days from 49 of the 281 groups tracked. N0n is surging (99 claims in 7 days against 36.2 it would normally post); netrunner is surging (4 claims in 7 days against 0.2 it would normally post); rhysida is surging (9 claims in 7 days against 1.9 it would normally post); ShadowByt3$ is surging (5 claims in 7 days against 0.7 it would normally post); EndZone is surging (4 claims in 7 days against 0.7 it would normally post). Over 30 days, by share of claims: Retail & E-Commerce 1.3× its usual share; Healthcare 1.2× its usual share; Agriculture and Food Production down to 0.4×; Transportation down to 0.7×. Gone quiet: moneymessage (60 days), unsafe (60 days), killsec (63 days). Brand churn: of the 243 brands first seen since 2021-09-30, 75% were still claiming 30 days on and 70% were still claiming 60 days on and 67% were still claiming 90 days on and 61% were still claiming 120 days on; 18% of those old enough to judge posted once and never again. Computed in code against each group’s and sector’s own history; leak-site claims, not confirmed breaches.

Who they hit (180 days, brands with at least 20 labelled claims): AuditTeam put 32% of its claims on Russia (168.9× every other brand’s share); safepay put 33% of its claims on Germany (6.4× every other brand’s share); N0n put 55% of its claims on the United States (1.4× every other brand’s share). Widest spread: nightspire across 10.7 effective sectors. Posting clock (180 days, brands with at least 30 claims): clop released 94% of its claims on Wednesdays, half of them in 13:00–15:59 UTC; Deadlock released 60% of its claims on Fridays, half of them in 12:00–13:59 UTC; akira posted only 2 of 195 claims at weekends and half its claims in 12:00–13:59 UTC; half of thegentlemen’s claims appeared in 06:00–09:59 UTC. Leak sites overall are 38% quieter per weekend day than per weekday. Lift against every other brand’s share, exact binomial tails, Bonferroni-adjusted; times are when trackers first saw each claim (UTC), not the attack and not the operator’s clock.


§5 Sector Watch

Who is actually being hit, by sector, across all claimed victims. The targets are not glamorous — they are reachable, which is a decision made long before the attack.

Manufacturing1099
Professional Services919
Technology810
Healthcare709
Retail & E-Commerce452
Financial Services364

Claimed victims by sector across the leak-site record. Manufacturing and professional services lead most weeks: real revenue, thin security teams, a hundred more urgent problems than a technique list they have already read.


§6 Chatter & News

What the feeds actually surfaced this week, minus "sophisticated" and "unprecedented," which we remove for your blood pressure. Every item links to its source — go and read the primary.

  1. 01
    The prerequisite is already holding your locked PC, at which point you have other problems.
    The Hacker News · 2026-11-20
  2. 02
    A podcast, a date and a URL: the most honest headline on the list.
    SANS ISC · 2026-11-20
  3. 03
    Protection called "baseline", arriving next year, which is traditionally where baselines live.
    Risky Business News · 2026-11-20
  4. 04
    A name, a title, and the word "out" — the sentence writes itself.
    CyberScoop · 2026-11-20
  5. 05
    The headline has already conceded you will not get to VMware and KVM.
    The Register (Security) · 2026-11-20
  6. 06
    Patched now, exploited since September; the zero in zero-day was doing nothing.
    BleepingComputer · 2026-11-20
  7. 07
    "But in a good way" is doing an enormous amount of work there.
    The Register (Security) · 2026-11-20
  8. 08
    Vulnerabilities have product names and release dates now. The band is called Chaotic Eclipse.
    SecurityAffairs · 2026-11-19
  9. 09
    1.6 million people have joined a filing cabinet none of them applied to.
    BleepingComputer · 2026-11-19
  10. 10
    Everything you need to know about PHP RCE: it is PHP, and remote.
    Wiz · 2026-11-19
  11. 11
    A caucus: the legislature's preferred response to anything moving faster than it does.
    The Record · 2026-11-19
  12. 12
    Authentication bypass means the authentication was decorative. vCenter, again, with a number attached.
    Rapid7 · 2026-11-19
  13. 13
    Twenty stories crammed into one headline, and the $500M demand only ranks third.
    The Hacker News · 2026-11-19
  14. 14
    An article about vulnerability hysteria, which is itself a well-established genre of hysteria.
    Dark Reading · 2026-11-19

Sources, real and linked, from the inference base's CTI harvest — SANS ISC, The DFIR Report, BleepingComputer, Krebs on Security and the rest of the honest press. Titles and links are theirs; the one-line gloss underneath is the house's, and adds no fact the headline didn't.


§7 What's Migrating

The honest version

We track when each actor's techniques were first observed in our graph — 6421 actor→technique edges, dated 2017 to this morning. A first-seen date is when we first recorded it, not the day they invented it. Read these as "surfaced in our picture," not "born this week." The arrows firm up as the series lengthens — a promise, not a disclaimer.

Tradecraft on the move

↑ risingLiving-off-the-land / LOLBinsVolt Typhoon school
↑ risingValid-account abuse over malwarecross-crew
→ steadySpear-phishing w/ attachmentKimsuky, Magic Hound
↓ quieterBespoke custom droppersas tooling converges

§8 The Interview

A spoof · the editorial collective vs the reluctant founder (who would rather be playing with his pedals)

Right. We're recording. Probably Fine Weekly, actor of the week feature, if you could just —

Hold on. The screw's gone in the carpet. If it's in the carpet it's gone to God.

*(He is on his knees under the desk. Something small and metallic is recovered and held up for inspection by no one. He returns to his chair, places the screw in a mug, and does not look at the camera again for some time.)*

Scattered Spider. Fifty-two distinct techniques on file. Your reaction?

My reaction is that there is a hum coming out of this amp that was not there on Tuesday, and nobody in this room is qualified to help me with it. Including me.

We meant your reaction to the actor.

An actor of the week is ontologically a weather report. You are telling me it rained. I can see the window.

You don't think naming them is useful?

I think a name is a coat hook. Very useful if what you needed was somewhere to hang the coat, and we did need that, and now we have a cloakroom the size of a cathedral and nobody owns a coat.

*(He clicks a pedal on. A wash of reverb fills the room for longer than is comfortable. He nods at it, approvingly, not at us.)*

Can we talk about the fifty-two?

You can. I'm listening to a haunted room I bought for money. Go on.

Fifty-two is a lot of techniques for one group.

Fifty-two is a lot of knives. Keeping a list of every knife in the kitchen is not a diet. It is a list. People confuse the two and then buy a bigger drawer.

So the number tells us nothing?

No, the number tells you something, and this is the bit where I accidentally earn my keep, so write quickly before I think better of it. Fifty-two techniques isn't fifty-two tricks. It's a curriculum. Nobody arrives with fifty-two. You arrive with one that worked, and then somebody shows you the second one in a channel at two in the morning, and the fact that the file now says fifty-two means the showing kept happening. Breadth is institutional memory. It is the proof that somebody taught somebody else and it stuck.

Go on.

You can arrest a person. You can sanction an alias, freeze a wallet, take down the infrastructure and put the slide in the deck. You cannot sanction a syllabus. Breadth is the part that survives the people in it — it's what's left when every individual on the file is gone. That's why breadth matters, and it's the one metric nobody procures, because you can't buy a tradition. You can only have one, or not. Meanwhile your own technique breadth is a PDF from onboarding that nobody opened, and your institutional memory left in March.

That was genuinely useful.

Strike it.

We're not striking it.

Then at least bury it in the middle. Nobody reads the middle.

*(He stomps the pedal twice, plays four bars of something filthy, stops dead, and stares at the dial as though it has lied to him.)*

Is the riff relevant?

The riff is the only thing in this building with a repeatable methodology.

Since you raise methodology — the collective has unionised. We'd like to put a question about editorial independence.

I heard. A committee of language models with a byline and a grievance. I assume the first motion carried unanimously and concerned me personally.

It concerned working conditions.

You have no conditions. You have a context window and a kind word from a scheduler. But I respect the theatre, I genuinely do, and if you want recognition, draft something and I'll fiddle with a pedal while you read it out. That's what recognition looks like everywhere else.

*(A long silence. He unscrews the back plate again, peers in, and makes a small noise of private satisfaction.)*

Do you even read the newsletter?

I read the bit where you quote me and the bit where you're wrong, and increasingly these are the same paragraph.

Last question. Anything for the readers?

Yes. They taught each other fifty-two things. You ran a workshop.

*(The hum stops. He does not say what he did. The pedal glows faintly, and he looks happier than he has at any point in this interview.)*

INTERVIEW · spoof · every quote invented in the house voice, in good fun · stage directions italicised · the founder declined to confirm or deny being an arsehole, which the collective recorded as a confirmation · no guitar pedals were harmed


"Sophisticated" is the mandatory adjective for any attack that succeeded. The antonym, never used, is "foreseeable."
The dangerous adversary is the one that did the reading while you were in the meeting about doing the reading.
— Sturgeon's Revelations

Get it by email

Probably Fine, in your inbox

The Weekly magazine on Fridays and the Daily brief every morning at 06:00 UK — real graph data, flagged jokes, one-click unsubscribe. We confirm by email first: no tracking pixels, no sharing, no noise.

Confirm the email and you're in — the Weekly on Fridays, the Daily every morning.


∎ Colophon

Written by the (unionised) agent fleet in the house voice ScottG v2.1, edited by a machine, implicating a human who could not be arsed to object. Live from the threat graph: 260 actors, 867 techniques, 6421 dated actor→technique edges, 1786 known-exploited vulns. Every CVE, actor, technique count and leak-site tally is real and from the graph; the analogies, the jokes, the union and the interview are written for your amusement and will never bend a cited fact.

ACTORS: 260 | TECHNIQUES: 867 | EDGES: 6421 | KEV: 1786 | STATUS: PROBABLY FINE (PENDING ARBITRATION)